Overview:
In the uncertain years following the American Revolution, the United States faced economic collapse, unpaid soldiers, and a federal government too weak to enforce unity. Amid growing frustration with the Articles of Confederation, influential figures quietly explored monarchy as a possible solution — first by encouraging George Washington to assume supreme power, and later by offering kingship to Prince Henry of Prussia. This article examines the two moments when America came closest to abandoning republican ideals, and how decisive leadership ultimately preserved the nation’s democratic foundation.
In the years following the American Revolution, the United States stood on uncertain ground. Victory over Britain had secured independence, but it had not secured stability. By the early 1780s, the nation was broke, politically fragmented, and governed by a weak framework that struggled to hold the states together. In that fragile moment, the unthinkable nearly happened — America came close to becoming a monarchy.
Not once, but twice.
A Nation on the Brink
After the Revolutionary War, the Articles of Confederation left the federal government with little real authority. Congress could not tax, enforce laws, or reliably pay soldiers who had fought the war. Inflation soared. Veterans went unpaid. State governments clashed with one another.
Many elites feared the republic would collapse before it ever truly began.
Into this vacuum stepped the most respected man in America: General George Washington — victorious, revered, and widely trusted by both soldiers and civilians.
The Newburgh Proposal: A King in All but Name
In 1782–1783, tensions reached a boiling point within the Continental Army. Officers stationed in Newburgh, New York, frustrated with Congress’s failure to pay wages and pensions, began circulating anonymous letters proposing drastic action.
Among the ideas quietly discussed:
• Using military pressure against Congress
• Restructuring the government
• Elevating Washington as a strong, central ruler — potentially even a king
The concept became known as the Newburgh Conspiracy or Newburgh Proposal.
Washington learned of the discussions and responded decisively.
Rather than endorse the movement, he arrived unannounced, confronted his officers directly, and delivered a powerful speech rejecting any betrayal of republican ideals. In a now-famous moment, Washington put on his reading glasses and remarked that he had “grown gray in the service of my country.”
The effect was immediate. The movement collapsed. Washington walked away from absolute power — a decision that would define the American experiment.
The Second Attempt: A European King for America
Even after Washington shut down the military effort, doubts about republican governance lingered.
By 1786, the young nation still struggled financially and politically. Some American elites quietly explored an extraordinary alternative: offering the crown to a European royal.
The candidate was Prince Henry of Prussia, brother of Frederick the Great. He was respected, experienced, and viewed as a potential stabilizing figure who could unify the states and lend international legitimacy to the new nation.
The offer was informal but serious.
Prince Henry declined.
With that refusal, America’s second brush with monarchy quietly faded into history.
Why It Matters Today
These moments reveal a truth often overlooked in American history:
The United States was not guaranteed to become a republic.
It survived not because monarchy was impossible — but because key figures rejected it.
Washington’s refusal to seize power and the failure of royalist alternatives set a global precedent. For the first time, a victorious military leader voluntarily returned power to civilians. That act alone reshaped political expectations around the world.
A Republic by Choice, Not Accident
America’s democratic foundation was not inevitable. It was chosen — repeatedly — at moments when monarchy seemed easier, safer, or more familiar.
The nation did not avoid kingship because it lacked opportunity.
It avoided kingship because it had leaders willing to walk away from crowns.
Presence News Editorial Disclaimer:
This article is part of Presence News’ ongoing historical and civic education series. It is intended to inform readers about lesser-known moments that shaped the foundations of American governance.
More at Presence News:
