Overview:
TikTok has fundamentally changed how audiences judge news credibility. Instead of relying on institutional authority or documented sources, users increasingly trust what feels authentic, relatable, and widely engaged with. In this Presence News feature, five experts explore how short-form video has redefined trust signals, elevated engagement metrics over editorial oversight, and accelerated the fragmentation of truth ecosystems. As TikTok enters a new ownership era, industry leaders predict further decentralization of credibility — requiring media organizations and brands to adapt rapidly without sacrificing verification standards.
By Presence News
How do people decide what news to trust in 2026?
For decades, credibility was tied to institutional authority — established outlets, official press releases, and credentialed experts. But as short-form video platforms reshape media consumption, that equation has changed. And no platform has accelerated that shift more than TikTok.
Presence News posed a timely question to experts:
How has TikTok changed the way news credibility is judged, and what shifts do you expect as the platform enters a new ownership era?
Out of 55 submissions, we selected five standout perspectives that capture how credibility is evolving — and where it may be heading next.
From Institutional Authority to Personal Authenticity
Rusty Rich, President of Latitude Park, says TikTok has “completely rewired what brands consider trustworthy.”
In his view, the old playbook — verified accounts, official statements, carefully crafted press releases — has been replaced by something much faster and less centralized.
“A 19-year-old in their bedroom can fact-check a CNN segment in 45 seconds, get 2M views, and suddenly they’re the authority because the comment section agrees and the duet chain keeps building.”
Mr. Rich described a real-world example involving a franchise client facing a food safety rumor. While corporate leadership drafted a traditional response, TikTok creators were already producing dozens of reactive videos. By the time legal approvals were complete, the narrative had hardened online.
The solution? Rapid, localized responses from micro-influencers.
Speed and relatability, he says, now outweigh formal authority.
Style Over Sources?
Jennifer Bagley, CEO of CI Web Group, sees a similar pattern.
“TikTok has trained people to judge news on sight, valuing style over sources.”
She notes that audiences increasingly trust what feels authentic — even when verification is thin. As regulatory or ownership changes potentially bring tighter moderation rules, she expects a renewed need for visible fact-checking tools.
But there’s a paradox:
To earn trust on TikTok, brands must move quickly — while simultaneously proving they aren’t improvising the truth.
The Military Information Challenge
Larry Fowler, President of USMilitary.com, offers a particularly urgent perspective.
For veterans seeking information about VA benefits, disability claims, or housing assistance, accuracy isn’t optional — it’s critical.
“Credibility comes from perceived authenticity in the first three seconds of a video,” he says. “The algorithm rewards emotion and speed over accuracy.”
Fowler has seen detailed, thoroughly verified guides receive less traction than short clips delivered with confidence and authority. For younger service members, the distinction between lived experience and documented fact can blur quickly — especially when someone appears on camera in uniform.
His organization has adapted by creating short-form hooks that direct viewers to longer, verified resources. In other words, meeting the algorithm halfway without abandoning documentation.
Fragmented Truth Ecosystems
Sarah DeLary, Owner of Real Marketing Solutions, believes TikTok fundamentally shifted credibility from institutions to individuals.
“People now trust a 23-year-old explaining economic policy in 60 seconds over traditional news outlets — not because the information is more accurate, but because the delivery feels more genuine.”
She expects new ownership to accelerate what’s already happening: fragmentation.
Instead of one dominant trust hierarchy, audiences now exist inside creator ecosystems. Different feeds generate different realities, reinforced by engagement patterns and algorithmic reinforcement.
For brands and publishers, DeLary advises diversification. Relying on any single platform — or assuming institutional credibility alone is enough — is no longer viable.
Engagement as Verification
Alvin Poh, Chairman of Singapore Domain Names, approaches the issue from a cloud and digital infrastructure standpoint.
He observes that credibility signals on TikTok are increasingly tied to engagement metrics:
- Views
- Likes
- Shares
- Comments
A video with 500,000 likes feels more legitimate than a detailed PDF with citations — even when the reverse may be true.
If ownership changes lead to stricter moderation or new transparency tools, Mr Poh believes credibility features could improve. However, he cautions that user habits formed over years won’t shift overnight.
The Bigger Shift: Perception vs. Proof
Across all five expert perspectives, a consistent theme emerges:
Credibility on TikTok is judged through perception first — verification second.
The platform’s structure favors:
- Speed over deliberation
- Relatability over credentials
- Emotion over documentation
- Engagement over editorial oversight
As TikTok enters a new ownership chapter, fragmentation may increase. Audiences could disperse across clone apps or alternative platforms. But the underlying behavioral shift — judging truth by how it feels — is unlikely to disappear.
For news organizations, brands, and civic institutions, the challenge is clear:
- Adapt to short-form speed.
- Maintain verification standards.
- Build trust ecosystems that extend beyond any single platform.
The ownership question matters.
But the deeper transformation has already happened.
Editor’s Note:
55 experts submitted responses to this query. Presence News selected five responses that best captured the structural changes shaping digital credibility in 2026.
More at Presence News:
