Overview:
A recent vandalism and arson case in Wethersfield, Connecticut — where police filed a report and made arrests — has renewed questions from local business owners across the state who say similar incidents were not documented by police, leaving them unable to recover losses through insurance.
A Case Where a Police Report Was Filed
Earlier this month, Wethersfield Police announced that two teenagers were charged after allegedly setting fire to multiple portable toilets at the historic Solomon Welles House, causing property damage and prompting an investigation.
According to public reporting, police documented the incident, conducted an investigation, and filed formal charges, which allowed the matter to proceed through the criminal justice system. The case was publicly acknowledged, and a police report was generated as part of the process.
For some local business owners, the Wethersfield case represents what they say should happen whenever vandalism or arson causes significant property damage.
Business Owners Say Their Vandalism Was Not Documented
By contrast, Connecticut business owners have told Presence News that after experiencing vandalism — including destroyed equipment, arson attempts, and significant financial losses — police departments in their jurisdictions declined to file police reports or open investigations.
According to these accounts, business owners were told:
- The damage should be handled internally
- Insurance companies should be contacted directly
- Filing reports could negatively impact crime statistics
- Crime data might affect state funding or property values
In some cases, owners say the damage exceeded several thousand dollars per incident, and occurred repeatedly over time. One theft of over $11,000 of equipment had no investigation.
Insurance Claims Often Require Police Reports
Insurance professionals note that police reports are commonly required to process vandalism or arson claims, particularly when criminal activity is alleged.
Business owners told Presence News that when they attempted to file insurance claims, they were informed that reimbursement could not proceed without an official police report documenting the incident.
Without that documentation:
- Claims may be delayed or denied
- Losses remain unrecoverable
- Patterns of vandalism are not formally recorded
This creates a situation where the absence of a police report effectively shifts the financial burden entirely onto the victim.
What Connecticut Law Says — and Doesn’t Say
Connecticut law clearly defines criminal mischief and arson as crimes when property is intentionally damaged or destroyed. When arrests are made, police reports are standard.
However, state statutes do not explicitly require police to file a report for every reported act of vandalism, leaving discretion at the departmental level for lower-level or unresolved incidents.
Legal experts note that this discretion can lead to inconsistent outcomes across municipalities, where similar acts of vandalism are documented in one town but not another.
Why Consistency Matters
Public safety advocates argue that consistent reporting practices are essential because:
- Crime trends cannot be accurately tracked without reports
- Businesses cannot protect themselves financially without documentation
- Selective reporting may undermine public trust
- Communities may receive an incomplete picture of local crime
The Wethersfield case demonstrates that when vandalism is formally documented, accountability and legal resolution become possible.
A Call for Transparency and Clarity
As small businesses continue to face rising costs and economic pressure, the question remains whether Connecticut should adopt clearer statewide guidance on when police reports must be generated for vandalism and property damage.
For business owners, the issue is not just about crime statistics — it is about basic documentation, insurance protection, and equal treatment under the law.
Sources
- Patch: Two Teens Charged After Toilets Torched at Historic Site, Wethersfield Police
- Connecticut General Statutes §53a-115 to §53a-117 (Criminal Mischief)
- Connecticut General Statutes §53a-111 to §53a-113 (Arson)
More at Presence News:
