Overview:
Presence News invites readers to submit their conspiracy theories for investigation. This article explores why conspiracy theories captivate us, examines one famous myth proven false and one proven true, and explains how readers can participate in uncovering fact from fiction.
The Allure (and Danger) of Conspiracy Theories
Conspiracy theories have long occupied a curious place in public discourse. On one hand, they speak to a fundamental human impulse: to make sense of events that feel random, complex, or malevolent. On the other hand, unchecked conspiratorial thinking can spread misinformation, deepen societal mistrust, or even foster radicalization.
Conspiracy narratives often thrive because they offer simplified explanations for complex events — filling gaps where official answers seem unsatisfying. They blend skepticism, creativity, and fear, making them both contagious and convincing.
But not all conspiracies are created equal. Some collapse under scrutiny, while others reveal disturbing truths. That’s why Presence News is launching a new reader initiative: you send us your theories, and we’ll investigate them — methodically, objectively, and transparently.
editor@presencenews.org <– Email them in!
A Myth That Was Proven False: The “Irish Slaves” Narrative
One example of a conspiracy-tinged myth that has been thoroughly debunked is the “Irish slaves” narrative. This myth claims that in early colonial America, masses of Irish people were enslaved in conditions identical to African chattel slavery — a theory often used to diminish the horrors of African enslavement.
In reality, historians and researchers have shown this narrative to be misleading and false. While some Irish people were indentured servants who endured harsh conditions, they retained legal rights, defined service terms, and the eventual promise of freedom. This system was categorically different from the racialized, lifelong slavery imposed on Africans and their descendants.
The myth gained new life through viral memes and fringe blogs, which distorted or fabricated historical documents. Scholars now cite it as an example of how misinformation, driven by political or cultural motives, can reshape public understanding of history.
In short: the “Irish slaves” conspiracy is a myth that doesn’t stand up to evidence.
A Conspiracy with a Kernel of Truth: MKUltra
While many conspiracies crumble under scrutiny, history also shows that some suspicions are justified. One of the most infamous examples is the CIA’s Project MKUltra — a covert program that conducted human experimentation during the Cold War.
Beginning in the 1950s, the CIA secretly tested the effects of LSD and other substances on unwitting participants, attempting to develop methods of mind control and psychological manipulation. Many test subjects never gave consent, and documentation of these experiments remained hidden for decades.
In the 1970s, U.S. congressional hearings and declassified records confirmed the existence of MKUltra. The revelation shocked the public and permanently altered how Americans viewed government secrecy. It also led to reforms governing human-subject research and intelligence oversight.
This serves as a reminder that while many conspiracies are false, others expose uncomfortable truths hidden in plain sight. Blind dismissal can be as dangerous as blind belief.
How to Submit a Conspiracy Theory to Presence News
We’re inviting our readers to share their theories for investigation. Whether it’s a small-town mystery or a global claim, we’ll evaluate the evidence with objectivity and care.
What to Include in Your Submission:
- Summary (1–2 paragraphs):
What is the claim? Who are the alleged actors? What events does it involve? - Evidence:
Include documents, links, interviews, or other proof — even partial information helps. - Counterpoints:
If you’re aware of any fact-checks or debunkings, include them. We value full context. - Your perspective (optional):
Do you believe the claim, or are you simply curious to know the truth? - Contact information:
Include an email or pseudonym so we can follow up if needed.
We Will Not Cover:
- Personal accusations without evidence (Public Information)
- Material that violates privacy laws or copyrights
- Theories based entirely on satire or fiction
Our Review Process:
- Screening: We verify that submissions are credible enough to investigate.
- Research: Our reporters and fact-checkers analyze the claim using academic, governmental, and open-source data.
- Expert Consultation: When needed, we reach out to scholars, scientists, or legal professionals.
- Publication: We present the claim, evidence, counter-evidence, and our conclusion — clearly labeling what’s proven, unproven, or impossible to verify.
Why Reader Submissions Matter
Crowdsourcing investigations helps democratize truth-seeking. Many major stories — from environmental whistleblowing to political scandals — began with public tips. You may hold a clue no one else has noticed.
By submitting your theory, you’re not just sharing a suspicion. You’re joining a conversation about how we know what’s true in an age of digital deception. Presence News believes in confronting misinformation not by silencing it, but by exposing it to the light of verifiable fact.
Tips: Spotting Red Flags in Conspiracy Claims
| Warning Sign | Ask Yourself |
|---|---|
| Vague “they” references | Who specifically? What documents name them? |
| All-encompassing explanations | Does the theory claim to explain everything? |
| Lack of motive | Why would the conspirators do this? |
| “Evidence” only on anonymous forums | Can it be verified elsewhere? |
| Inability to be disproven | If every contradiction is part of the plot, it’s not testable. |
Being skeptical of both official and unofficial narratives is healthy — but skepticism must be paired with methodology.
Your Turn: Join the Investigation
We want your theories. Whether you think NASA faked a discovery, corporations are hiding technologies, or your local town hall is up to something, send it in.
Email: editor@presencenews.org
Subject line: Conspiracy Theory Submission
Include your supporting details, any links, and what outcome you’d like us to explore. We’ll handle each submission confidentially and transparently.
Together, we can transform rumor into reason — and make truth the loudest voice in the room.
Sources
- “11 Unbelievable Conspiracy Theories That Were Actually True” – HowStuffWorks
- “Conspiracy Theories Debunked: The Truth Behind Popular Myths” – History Collection
- “Irish Slaves Myth” – Wikipedia
- “Fake or Fact: How to Recognise a Conspiracy Theory” – The Guardian
- “Conspiracy Narratives as a Type of Social Myth” – PMC
- “American Conspiracy Theories Polls & Myths” – National Geographic
More at Presence:
