Arrest
On November 24, 2025, Scot D. Thompson, 65, of Englewood, Florida, was arrested by the New York State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation out of SP Amity. He is charged with two counts of Murder in the 2nd Degree and two counts of Criminal Use of a Firearm.
What Happened?
Investigators say a physical altercation unfolded at a hunting cabin on Botsford Hollow Road in the Town of Allen. During the confrontation, Scot Thompson allegedly shot and killed his brothers:
- Mark B. Thompson, 70, of Canterbury, Connecticut
- David E. Thompson, 69, of Port Charlotte, Florida
The reasons for the dispute have not yet been disclosed.
On the Run
Following the fatal shooting, Thompson reportedly left the scene using David Thompson’s vehicle. Law enforcement agencies were alerted and quickly began circulating information about the car.
Capture
The Geneseo Police Department later located the vehicle. Scot Thompson was subsequently taken into custody without incident.
What Now?
As of this report, Thompson is being processed and will be transported to the Allegany County Jail. Autopsies for Mark and David Thompson will be conducted at Strong Memorial Hospital.
Source
New York State Police – Public Release
(Original report: https://troopers.ny.gov/news/double-homicide-town-allen)
Editor Disclaimer
Editor’s Note: The details in this report are based on information released by law enforcement. All individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. If you have ANY information to help in the investigation of this case PLZ if you see something say something.
